A Manhattan federal judge on November 20, 2026, rejected the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) emergency attempt to stop New York from pursuing its enforcement case against prediction-market operator Kalshi, Reuters reported. The decision leaves the state’s request for restrictions to be considered in state court. Reuters’ November 20 reporting

The previous day, U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick ordered the attorney general’s lawsuit returned to the Supreme Court of New York, New York County. Together, the November 19 remand and November 20 ruling put the dispute back before Manhattan’s state judiciary. Broderick’s November 19 opinion and order

The state’s case predates this week’s rulings

Attorney General Letitia James and Governor Kathy Hochul announced the lawsuit on July 31, 2026. Their office alleges that Kalshi operates an unlicensed gambling platform and exposes people under New York’s legal sports-wagering age of 21 to financial risk. The state seeks restitution, forfeiture of alleged illegal gains and financial penalties. These are the state’s allegations and requested remedies; the July announcement is background to this week’s proceedings. The attorney general’s July 31 announcement

The platform allows people to take positions on the outcomes of future events, including sports, elections and cultural events. That range is part of what makes the dispute consequential for technology businesses: the same online service can be described through the lens of financial-market regulation or gambling regulation, with different institutions asserting authority over its activity.

What the remand decided

Broderick’s order addresses the court that may hear the state’s case. Kalshi had argued that its federal regulatory status and federal-law issues justified moving the proceeding out of state court. The judge rejected the asserted grounds for federal jurisdiction. He also declined to award New York attorneys’ fees and costs, finding Kalshi had presented arguments that were sufficiently reasonable to avoid such an award. The remand decision’s reasoning and disposition

The order did not decide Kalshi’s request for protection from an investigative subpoena, because the federal court lacked jurisdiction. Its background section expressly says its factual account should not be treated as findings of fact. The immediate result is a change of forum, with the underlying dispute continuing.

For readers following the case, that procedural distinction matters. An order returning a lawsuit to another court is a step in deciding where the arguments will be heard. The requested restrictions on the service, their wording and any eventual determination of liability require their own decisions. A headline about a courtroom setback cannot substitute for reading the relief actually granted.

A second federal judge declines emergency intervention

Reuters reported that Judge Lorna G. Schofield denied the CFTC’s November 20 request because the agency had not demonstrated likely success on its argument that federal law prevents states from enforcing their gambling laws against prediction-market operators. The CFTC treats Kalshi’s contracts as swaps and asserts exclusive jurisdiction over derivatives markets. Reuters on Schofield’s ruling and the CFTC’s position

ABC News reported that Kalshi attorney Sean Murphy warned the state judge that a temporary restraining order could require liquidation of open positions and disrupt markets outside New York. At the federal hearing, CFTC attorney Andrew Weisberg also argued that the proposed state order could shut down Kalshi’s nationwide operations. Those were arguments about a possible order’s consequences. ABC News’ account of the November 20 proceedings

The state disputed the emergency-intervention case. According to ABC, attorney Kate Rhodes Janofsky argued that a scheduled state-court hearing left no basis for federal intervention and that evidence of market disruption had not been supplied. ABC reported that Justice Melissa Crane set a hearing for Monday, November 23, on the requested temporary restraining order.

Why this matters in New York

The local significance is concrete: Manhattan courts are considering how state enforcement applies to an online exchange whose activity reaches beyond the state. For New York’s financial technology sector, the proceedings illustrate how questions about a service’s legal classification can become questions about its continued operation and treatment of existing customer positions.

The next development to watch is the state court’s handling of the requested relief. Any resulting order’s scope, effective date and treatment of open positions will be more informative than either side’s forecast. The November 19 and 20 decisions establish the procedural setting for that next stage; they leave the competing accounts of Kalshi’s obligations and the proposed restrictions’ effects to be resolved.